Sign In or Register Here


2 plus zero

Please enter your e-mail address below. We will email you a link to reset your password.

5 minus three

To complete your registration, please verify your email address.

8 minus two

We have sent an email to the address you provided. Please click the link in the email to confirm your email address.

Your account has been marked for password reset. Please change your password.

7 plus five

Only registered ICC members have access to this article at this time.

Explore all the benefits that ICC Membership has to offer and become a member today to gain access to this exciting content.

If you're already an ICC member Sign In Now.


Can We Help?
  • Reset My Password
  • I Need More Help
Family of Solutions menu icon
  • ICC Family of Solutions
  • ICCSafe
  • myICC
  • Digital Codes
  • cdpACCESS
  • Store
  • Support
Skip to Main Content
  • ICC Main
  • myICC
  • BSJ
  • Journal
  • Store
  • Store
  • cdpACCESS
  • cdpACCESS
  • Digital Codes
  • Help
  • Help
    • ICC Family of Solutions
    • ICCSafe
    • myICC
    • Digital Codes
    • cdpACCESS
    • Store
    • Support
Building Safety Journal Logo
Building Safety Journal Logo
  • Archive
    • March, 2023 Articles
    • Febuary, 2023 Articles
    • January, 2023 Articles
    • December, 2022 Articles
    • November, 2022 Articles
    • October, 2022 Articles
    • 2023 Articles
    • 2022 Articles
  • Browse by Category
    • Deep Dives
    • Member News
    • Personal Perspectives
    • Quick Hits
    • Technical Topics
    • Press Releases
    • Sponsored Content
    • View All
  • Browse by Topic
    • Buildings, Construction, Architecture/Design
    • Fire, Wildland-Urban Interface
    • Plumbing, Mechanical, Fuel Gas, Pools/Spas
    • Energy, Solar, Green, Sustainability
    • Disaster Preparedness, Mitigation, Resiliency
  • Subscribe
  • Family of Solutions menu icon
    • ICC Family of Solutions
    • ICCSafe
    • myICC
    • Digital Codes
    • cdpACCESS
    • Store
    • Support

Join today!

Keep up-to-date on crucial industry news, innovative training and expert technical advice with a free subscription to the award-winning Building Safety Journal.

Subscribe
  • Archive
    • March, 2023 Articles
    • Febuary, 2023 Articles
    • January, 2023 Articles
    • December, 2022 Articles
    • November, 2022 Articles
    • October, 2022 Articles
    • 2023 Articles
    • 2022 Articles
  • Browse by Category
    • Deep Dives
    • Member News
    • Personal Perspectives
    • Quick Hits
    • Technical Topics
    • Press Releases
    • Sponsored Content
    • View All
  • Browse by Topic
    • Buildings, Construction, Architecture/Design
    • Fire, Wildland-Urban Interface
    • Plumbing, Mechanical, Fuel Gas, Pools/Spas
    • Energy, Solar, Green, Sustainability
    • Disaster Preparedness, Mitigation, Resiliency
  • Subscribe
  • Archive
    • March, 2023 Articles
    • Febuary, 2023 Articles
    • January, 2023 Articles
    • December, 2022 Articles
    • November, 2022 Articles
    • October, 2022 Articles
    • 2023 Articles
    • 2022 Articles
  • Browse by Category
    • Deep Dives
    • Member News
    • Personal Perspectives
    • Quick Hits
    • Technical Topics
    • Press Releases
    • Sponsored Content
    • View All
  • Browse by Topic
    • Buildings, Construction, Architecture/Design
    • Fire, Wildland-Urban Interface
    • Plumbing, Mechanical, Fuel Gas, Pools/Spas
    • Energy, Solar, Green, Sustainability
    • Disaster Preparedness, Mitigation, Resiliency
  • Subscribe

Magistrate judge recommends finding IAPMO liable for copyright infringement

The judge overwhelmingly agreed with ICC-ES arguments that IAMPO made unauthorized copies of ICC-ES Evaluation Reports and Acceptance Criteria

August 8th, 2022
by Melike Oncu
  • Member News

On April 27, 2022, United States Magistrate Judge Zia Faruqui issued a report recommending that the United States District Court for the District of Columbia find that the International Association of Plumbing and Mechanical Officials, Inc., and IAPMO Evaluation Service, LLC (IAPMO-ES) (collectively IAPMO) infringed the copyrights for 26 ICC Evaluation Service (ICC-ES) evaluation reports and acceptance criteria. The magistrate judge overwhelmingly agreed with ICC-ES’s arguments, finding, among other things, that:

  1. ICC-ES owns valid and protectable copyrights in the evaluation reports and acceptance criteria;
  2. IAPMO infringed ICC-ES’s copyrighted works through reproduction and distribution of the copyrighted works on IAPMO’s internal systems; and
  3. ICC-ES is entitled to a permanent injunction prohibiting IAPMO and their employees and agents from any infringement of ICC-ES’s current and future copyrighted works.

The magistrate judge’s report is an important development in ICC-ES’s litigation against IAPMO, but it is not a final decision and will be reviewed by the District Court Judge who will issue a separate decision.

ICC-ES also argued that IAPMO infringed their copyrights in these works through the creation of competing IAPMO evaluation reports and acceptance criteria (Accused Works) that were undisputedly created by copying material from each of ICC-ES’s copyrighted works. Although the magistrate judge stated that IAPMO “overtly copied and repurposed competitor work[s]” in “shades of The Colbuffington Re-Post,[1]” he recommended that ICC-ES’s copyright infringement claims related to the Accused Works proceed to trial. Likewise, although the magistrate judge recognized that ICC-ES “proffer[ed] a wealth of evidence suggesting [IAPMO] knew they were infringing upon [ICC-ES’s] copyrights,” he recommended that the question of whether IAPMO’s infringement was willful be decided by a jury. The report also rejected IAPMO’s arguments that it was entitled to summary judgment, that ICC-ES’s works were not protectable, and that IAPMO’s use of ICC-ES’s works constituted non-infringing fair use.

After the report issued, IAPMO moved to seal the report from disclosure to the public, claiming that it contained “sensitive business information and trade secrets.” The magistrate judge denied IAPMO’s motion because “evidence of [IAPMO’s] impermissible copying and storing [ICC-ES’s] work—the central copyright infringement allegations in this case—are not the type of business practices in which Defendants have a proprietary interest.”  The full text of the report is available here.

Find out more about ICC-ES’s lawsuit against IAPMO.

  

About the lawsuit 

On Jan. 13, 2016, ICC-ES, a member of the International Code Council family of solutions, filed a lawsuit against IAPMO in the United States District Court for the District of Columbia for copyright infringement of ICC’s proprietary evaluation reports and acceptance criteria. 

Read more:

U.S. Federal District Court clears path for ICC copyright complaint against IAPMO

Pattern of IAPMO copyright violations short circuits process that promotes public safety in buildings, lawsuit asserts

 

About the Author
Melike Oncu
Melike Oncu is general counsel for the International Code Council. In her role, Oncu serves as a member of the Code Council senior management team and oversees all legal affairs for the Code Council and its family of solutions. Oncu holds a juris doctorate from George Washington University and a bachelor’s degree from Lafayette College. She began her legal career as a corporate attorney with the law firm White & Case, LLP. She also served as counsel for the law firm of Bingham McCutchen, LLP.
Submissions
Check out upcoming BSJ topics and send us articles for consideration:
Or send by email

Want to advertise in the BSJ?
Click Here

Share on Facebook
Facebook
Tweet about this on Twitter
Twitter
Share on LinkedIn
Linkedin

  • Clariti Software
    ICC ad 1 002
  • EduCode 2023
    22 21911 LC 2023 EduCODE BSJ 270x270 WAD FINAL
  • 21 20095 AC IECC HERS Why Work Skyscraper 270x270 WEB FINAL
  • I-Code Essentials
    I Code Essentials Purchase Now
  • Spanish I-Codes
    2018 Spanish I Codes Purchase Now
  • 2021 I-Codes
    2021 I Codes Purchase Now
  • Building Resilience General Code
    buildingresilient ICC CLBCwebinar ad 295x315 002
  • 20 18972 SKGA Skyscraper 295x315 WAD FINAL
Live Chat
Live Chat
ICC ICC

Subscribe to the Building Safety Journal

Subscribe

Connect with Us

    

ICC Family of Solutions

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Contact Us
  • Accessibility Policy